| Game Date | Team 1 | Score | Team 2 | Score |
|---|
| Tue, 05/10/05 6:00 pm | Nipmuc Alumni | 15 | Plan 9 | 10 | | |
| Thu, 05/19/05 6:00 pm | Nipmuc Alumni | 15 | JuJuHex | 9 | | |
| Tue, 05/31/05 6:30 pm | Crossroads | 10 | Nipmuc Alumni | 15 | | |
| Thu, 06/02/05 6:00 pm | Baboon Heart | 7 | Nipmuc Alumni | 15 | | |
| Thu, 06/16/05 6:00 pm | Demons | 15 | Nipmuc Alumni | 8 | | |
| Thu, 06/16/05 6:30 pm | Polaroid | 15 | Nipmuc Alumni | 11 | | |
| Thu, 06/23/05 6:00 pm | Nipmuc Alumni | 0 | JuJuHex | 0 | | |
| Thu, 07/14/05 6:00 pm | Nipmuc Alumni | 15 | Get Flat Ultimate | 10 | | |
| Thu, 07/21/05 6:30 pm | Castaways | 10 | Nipmuc Alumni | 15 | | |
| Thu, 08/04/05 6:00 pm | Cornbread | 4 | Nipmuc Alumni | 15 | | |
| Thu, 08/11/05 6:45 pm | Nipmuc Alumni | 15 | Flying Salsa | 7 | | |
|